Has anyone famously spoken out about midrangebrosteptearout?

[yong]

I've spoken out about it.

It got me into trouble.

[parson]

I'LL GO ON RECORD SAYING IT AIN'T DUBSTEP

[parson]

this forum told me from the getgo that my music wasn't dubstep, so i've got no problem seeing brostep as not dubstep either

[yong]

this forum told me from the getgo that my music wasn't dubstep, so i've got no problem seeing brostep as not dubstep either

sigged

[evil madmen]

end of the day theres good & bad from both sides of the split....

i don't know why someone would slate a style....i can see why they'de slate somebody.....but some ott dubstep is amazing and some deep stuff is a bit boring...just like some deep stuff is mindblowing and some ott stuff is fucking pointless

Surprised to see this kind of statement from you

[milksnake]

In general the people making the heavier styles are doing it in an effort to take direct aim at the head of those who make pretentious statements such as Blackdown is quoted above.

Particularly the shit about how he built the scene, and that sort of thing. I mean really?

LOL yea that quote made my skin crawl alittle bit too.

[fractal]

i also would like to point out that where im from, milksnake is another word for penis

[L.o.s.]

In general the people making the heavier styles are doing it in an effort to take direct aim at the head of those who make pretentious statements such as Blackdown is quoted above.

Particularly the shit about how he built the scene, and that sort of thing. I mean really?

LOL yea that quote made my skin crawl alittle bit too.

first time i added someone to the block list!

now in a short time ive become rather addicted to it

[Wrongkey]

The problem is that there's a lot of people out there who'll kick off if they hear anything other than a sine wave in a tune, whereas they should be excited that one genre can spawn so many different styles. It's not that these new styles are replacing the original ones, but they are happening along side them, and I personally think that's a good thing. Some people just need to get off their high horses and shut up.

[witts]

Taken from Blackdowns interview with Loefah & Kryptic Minds

B: That seems really healthy, because it allows you to experiment in your own way. There was a time when people were copying Loefah, badly, because they thought it was ‘easy’ to write halfstep, though that time has now gone and since then people have gone on to copy Coki and Skream.

L: And that’s what the scene is now, just Coki and Skream clones.

S: Same as what happened with Pendulum. Exactly the same: a million clones

Not sure if this is any help?

[blackdown]

I'm not sure being critical about a certain (admittedly now major) niche in the style is a particularly positive thing to do. If somebody who made quality material of this ilk came out and criticized (for example) Blackdown & Dusk's work, would that be just as valid? It's all subjective to taste and outlook. They both have their place. But being critical whilst sat in your own corner is not the way forward. I'm sure there's poor quality Burial clones out there too

Hey Kion, hope you're cool.

As there's no objectivity, i'm sure you wont mind me saying in my subjective opinion, constructive critism is a positive sign of a functioning healthy community, evolving and in creative dialog with itself. Rather than suggesting that critism is itself inherantly negative, i'd be more worried about a scene where fans, producers, contributors, participants weren't free to express their viewpoint and feedback to those creating the music or putting on nights etc. After all, expressing your viewpoint is pretty much this forum's raison d'etre! if people want to critise the deeper stuff that's just as valid: there's tons of its that's very dull, not least the Burial clones you mention (i get sent at least one a month).

and joe, to your original question, i think it's a bit pointless looking for people to say 'wobble's not dubstep' as it clearly is. this whole debate emerged exactly because it is!

[setspeed]

....everything we tried to build as a scene

In general the people making the heavier styles are doing it in an effort to take direct aim at the head of those who make pretentious statements such as Blackdown is quoted above.

Particularly the shit about how he built the scene, and that sort of thing. I mean really?

I take it english isn't your first language?

[deamonds]

........

[SickMan D]

We don't need no Dev Paradox in dubstep, what is the point really?

[d'brickashaw ferguson]

Who really cares? It's only because people are so caught up in assigning music to certain genres that these debates ever arise. For me, the music Mala makes bears no relation to the stuff Rusko makes, they're only compared because of the meaningless term "dubstep".

[abs]

very true, it's all music really, names are just names.. in 10 years time dubstep will be uncool anyway and half of these producers will pretend they never had anything to do with it, while the guys who sidestepped the whole genre thing will emerge intact on the other end.

[cosmic revenge]

if there weren't shitty producers, and absolutely everything was pure quality, you wouldn't appreciate the brilliant stuff as much. its cliche to say this, but you can't have the sweet without the sour

[setspeed]

We don't need no Dev Paradox in dubstep, what is the point really?

we need more Dev Paradoxes in dubstep! We also need a couple of Joe Kinnears, a Noel Gallagher and a Michael Winner for larfs

[rob sparx]

We don't need no Dev Paradox in dubstep, what is the point really?

Without Paradox that Paradox Diss tune would never have been made - that was a work of comedy genius indeed although I do agree with Paradox that some of Pendulums music sounds like Kazoos (duh-da-da-duh-da-da) yea they've done plenty of polished turds but theres a world of idiots out there hungry for their next turd fix so fair play to them, laughing all the way the bank!

[kion]

..but theres a world of idiots out there hungry for their next turd fix so fair play to them..

why do dogs love eating poo.. I'll never get that.