I think there's a thread for all that sort of thing - best we don't get into individual feedback in here or the thread will get clogged up with it... Sorry!
Now den;
muteqx wrote:
It's funny, only a few hours after posting that, I had some thoughts in a similar direction myself, and realised that I've probably got the subwoofer turned up a bit too loud. So I turned the sub down so that the reference tracks sounded less muddy, and as you predicted, my tracks now sound a bit bright, and the reference material sounds pretty rounded again.
So anyway, this is the "knowing my system" part of it, and I think I just took a step closer to that. Shouldn't be a massive amount of work to go back and sort the current mixes out - I think overall, I'll probably end up just turning down other stuff relative to the bass, and maybe rolling a little off the mids and tops.
Have you done any measurements of your studio? Acoustics I mean? That will tell you what the score is... but certainly, having 'pro' tracks sounding good is a good place to start... Where does your sub cross over?
Kicks!!! I've rolled off most (not all) of the high-energy, low-frequency content of my kicks, so as to leave enough space for the bass. Would I be right in thinking that generally, you don't want to completely remove all low frequencies from your kick, just rein them in somewhat so that the bass has enough space to get through? I have a feeling I may have EQed them all a bit too much, so I now have punchy but not particularly hefty kick sounds.
I'd probably like a bit more low frequency content and meat in those kicks, but have become a bit scared of allowing it through, for fear that it will mess with the bass too much. Is it OK to have some low frequency kick content getting through as long as it doesn't get in the way of the bass and make things sound muddy down there?
I think you just answered this question yourself
Things will always overlap. Things sound better when they overlap! Just so long as it is controlled right, you'll get a full, clear sound. All this stuff about using 15 48db?oct filters on every sound to make it stop dead is bollocks - and wreaks havoc on the sound's phase response, making things even more unclear - defeating the object.
I've been writing electronic music for 18 years - more than half my life! Seems mad to still be asking these kind of questions, but I've never got as far as finishing an album before (and I may still kick the bucket before I finish this one LOL!), so much of this finishing off process is still new to me. Yesterday I ordered the Bob Katz "Mastering Audio" book and await it's arrival eagerly - time I plugged a few of these gaps in my knowledge.
It's a good book and well worth owning, but I dunno if it will answer many of these questions really. It's very dry, very processing-oriented and very technical. Very useful for mastering, but not so much for getting your mix right IMO. FWIW the bloke who edited it is my landlord... there you go.
Might you write a book one day Mr. Macc? Maybe there isn't much you can say which hasn't already been said before by someone else, but I like your way of explaining things because it's nice and clear - and often entertaining to read too. So, if you ever do write a book about your take on audio, I'd buy it and read it inside out! Here's hoping!
Haha, thanks man. It's something I have thought about, also teaching. This adds weight to the chances of me doing it some day... For now though, I have work to do
