Gutterbreakz is takin the piss!

docdoom · Post by **docdoom** » Mon May 22, 2006 3:43 pm

luke.envoy wrote:
bass clef wrote:I don't know how anyone could think that Gutta has anything but love for music and artists and he is so obviously just about spreading the word and getting more people into the sounds...
Those tunes were available for a handful of quick-witted people for a really short time
versus all the people who've heard tunes, bought tunes because of him...

get a grip
u give me jokes

if he loved the artists so much, then why didnt he ask them before giving their tracks away for free

dont tell people to get a grip when your not even taking basic respect for the artists into consideration

Not being funny mate but what other motivation could he possibly have for distributing the music other than out of love for it?

He's not making any money from it. He's not expecting anything back in return. He's not doing it to promote readership of his blog (anyone who has read it properly will know this).

So even if anyone disagree with it i think we should all remember first and foremost that he is a true soldier for the music we all love, supports his local scene, has spread the sound to lots of people and tirelessly gives props to the artists he respects.

Post by **dubway** » Mon May 22, 2006 3:44 pm

RobJC wrote:erm, how did this topic jump to the Dubstep page from Off Topic anyone????

i moved it

docdoom · Post by **docdoom** » Mon May 22, 2006 3:44 pm

luke.envoy wrote:
bass clef wrote:I don't know how anyone could think that Gutta has anything but love for music and artists and he is so obviously just about spreading the word and getting more people into the sounds...
Those tunes were available for a handful of quick-witted people for a really short time
versus all the people who've heard tunes, bought tunes because of him...

get a grip
u give me jokes

if he loved the artists so much, then why didnt he ask them before giving their tracks away for free

dont tell people to get a grip when your not even taking basic respect for the artists into consideration

Not being funny mate but what other motivation could he possibly have for distributing the music other than out of love for it?

He's not making any money from it. He's not expecting anything back in return. He's not doing it to promote readership of his blog (anyone who has read it properly will know this).

So even if anyone disagree with it i think we should all remember first and foremost that he is a soldier for the music we all love, supports his local scene, has spread the sound to lots of people and tirelessly gives props to the artists he respects. To construe him as anything other than that is to do him serious disservice, and one he does not diserve.

luke.envoy · Post by **luke.envoy** » Mon May 22, 2006 3:49 pm

docdoom, if someone decides to give away music that isnt theirs and without permission- whatever their incentive, there is no way that theyre gonna get let off just cause theyve supported the scene or really love the artists.

we all contribute to the scene and love the artists, but doesnt mean gutta should get some dubstep diplomatic immunity.

if hes been around so long he knew what he was doing. why state 'i havent asked the artists permission' in his blog, if it wasnt an issue?
one more time:

HE DIDNT ASK THE ARTISTS/LABELS

end of story

deapoh · Post by **deapoh** » Mon May 22, 2006 4:00 pm

I agree with what Luke Envoy is saying.

I would have at least asked the Artists if I can share their tunes for free and if not then fine move on. But without asking them is a bit rude. There is no consideration there, it's like he has forgotten the artists.

Having said that there was no need for the blog to shut down. All I would want to see is an appology to the artists. Nothing long, no more arguing.

luke.envoy · Post by **luke.envoy** » Mon May 22, 2006 4:02 pm

Deapoh wrote:All I would want to see is an appology to the artists. Nothing long, no more arguing.

init, that should have been the first thing to happen

dub boy · Post by **dub boy** » Mon May 22, 2006 4:08 pm

Big up Guttah!

Can't believe someone who's done so much for the scene is getting so much flack for this.

Keep up your good work Nick, fuck the haters

Rob H · Post by **Rob H** » Mon May 22, 2006 4:13 pm

hope the blogs only on a temporary hiatus, think gutter made a bit of a mistake but at the end of the day its obvious hes got a passion for the music and didnt intend to create all this controversy

robjc · Post by **robjc** » Mon May 22, 2006 4:17 pm

Dub boy wrote:Big up Guttah!

Can't believe someone who's done so much for the scene is getting so much flack for this.

Keep up your good work Nick, fuck the haters

Dub-boy - there's 2 parts to this thread - the valid one that Luke has about permission, and the other one that is slagging Gutta off.
Bigup the first one, thanks, but no thanks the second one.

Hopefully Gutta is looking through this and feeling the support from the majority of people - he acknowledged that he'd done bad when he got some private PM's - so lets all get down of our respective ivory towers now and usher this topic off the floor - Gutta will come back if he wants - totally up to him, but the world hasn't changed that much......

Rob H · Post by **Rob H** » Mon May 22, 2006 4:25 pm

agree completely

seckle · Post by **seckle** » Mon May 22, 2006 4:26 pm

i think after 7 pages of drama the point has been made. it's getting really old fast.

autonomic · Post by **autonomic** » Mon May 22, 2006 4:39 pm

luke.envoy wrote:
Deapoh wrote:All I would want to see is an appology to the artists. Nothing long, no more arguing.
init, that should have been the first thing to happen

gutta deserves one as well for that 'waceman' comment.

ufo over easy · Post by **ufo over easy** » Mon May 22, 2006 4:41 pm

I really hope he comes back to blogging, just because he's been so influential. I've met a ridiculous amount of people who cite gutterbreakz as the main reason they got into the music in the first place. Everyone makes mistakes, but an apology to he artists and labels or something would be nice

edited because that paragraph was really the only important bit.

widow twanky · Post by **widow twanky** » Mon May 22, 2006 4:43 pm

Give the man a break! He shared some tunes that are nearly all unavailable and stopped when he was asked. The bloke does loads for the music and is bang into it. What's all this having a go at him? Are the stakes really so high that we need to get nasty? Good on you Gutter!

rickyricardo · Post by **rickyricardo** » Mon May 22, 2006 4:48 pm

^^ not entirely true. You can find most of those Tempa bits damn near anywhere.

Intentions are one thing, but actions are another. It seemed like a bit of a shady thing to do from the get-go, especially when he caught enough flack for doing it the first time.

It seems like everyone's argument for Gutta seems to go back to how much he's done for the scene....but what about how much those artists have done for the scene, only to have 320 versions of their tunes posted on someones blog w/o their permission? I don't understand why Gutta somehow gets a pass for doing this kinda thing, that would get average joe blogger reamed into next Tuesday...

ufo over easy · Post by **ufo over easy** » Mon May 22, 2006 4:51 pm

Every one of those tunes is fairly easy to track down on vinyl or legal MP3, apart from the Loefah bit on Big Apple.

ramadanman · Post by **ramadanman** » Mon May 22, 2006 5:04 pm

exactly - WHY 320!

seriously...just make them like 128

widow twanky · Post by **widow twanky** » Mon May 22, 2006 5:05 pm

Every one of those tunes is fairly easy to track down on vinyl or legal MP3, apart from the Loefah bit on Big Apple

.

Really? Can you still get all that stuff? Well I stand corrected on that, but I still say lay off him. As I said, the stakes aren't so high as to justify all this nasty talk and insults. And that's not just as a favoured blogger or something, that's just not laying the boot in for the sake of it. And let's face it, we've all copied things for people so we're all guilty in a way. Or am I missing the point?

paulie · Post by **paulie** » Mon May 22, 2006 5:07 pm

Gutter's blog was easily the best covering this stuff. If he's taken it down permanently I think people contributing to this thread should be ashamed of themselves.

ufo over easy · Post by **ufo over easy** » Mon May 22, 2006 5:09 pm

widow twanky wrote: Really? Can you still get all that stuff? Well I stand corrected on that, but I still say lay off him. As I said, the stakes aren't so high as to justify all this nasty talk and insults. And that's not just as a favoured blogger or something, that's just not laying the boot in for the sake of it. And let's face it, we've all copied things for people so we're all guilty in a way. Or am I missing the point?

The tempa stuff's all been repressed recently, and the big apple bits are in at independence records...

But you're right

There's no need to be nasty about it, but it'd still be nice if Gutta admitted he'd made a mistake and apologised.

Paulie - would you still feel like that if Gutta had given away old Hot Flush bits on 320?

Gutterbreakz is takin the piss!

Who is online