Anders Behring Breivik is sane and gets 21yrs

[capo ultra]

kids in thailand got iphones and shit they don't need lberating

[Forum]

This isn't some criminal that got angry and shot someone in a fight.

Someone who meticulously plans the murder of 77 kids then smiles about it in court is surely beyond rehabilitation..

[capo ultra]

Mao rehabilitated shit loads of people

[capo ultra]

I think to get to the point where you could rehabilitate him it would be like 1984, pure brainwashing plain and simple

[Zambezi]

Not sure you understood 1984.

[noam]

This isn't some criminal that got angry and shot someone in a fight.

Someone who meticulously plans the murder of 77 kids then smiles about it in court is surely beyond rehabilitation..

if you give up before you've started how do will you ever learn to win??

if no one read Mein Kampff no one would know how terrible a book it was

if no one was allowed to voice the worst views one can have how can one know what good views are?

the death penalty is the same as censorship, you cant censor idea's out of existence, but you can set examples

im not saying pamper the guy and throw state money at him and set him up a new life somewhere

im saying that humans deserve to be treated a certain way, no matter who or what they are, because only by acting like this can we distance our actions from those performed by the people who need waking up

this whole argument is about how wrong it is of him to have killed so many people, why? because its a belief held by civilised people that humans have rights to life, to not be killed, and it is protecting this right at all costs which saves the idea.

as i said before, you kill the IDEA behind what he did by rehabilitating him and he and all his kind LOSE. you kill the people there'll be numerous others in their place

you dont build your house on an ants nest and spen the next 40 years killing ant after ant after ant... you build your house away from the ants nest and never worry about them.

[scspkr99]

And yet people want the state to kill an unarmed man for killing unarmed kids.

[espire]

I agree with Noam but it feels kinda weird to set Breivik free. Imagine what would happen if they let him go... I can't even imagine how furious the Norwegians would be.
I'm kinda curious if they are gonna keep adding 5years or if they'll eventually dare to try and rehabilitate him.

[capo ultra]

Not sure you understood 1984.

yea I did not sure if you did

[capo ultra]

everyone gets the death sentence in the end

[noam]

I agree with Noam but it feels kinda weird to set Breivik free. Imagine what would happen if they let him go... I can't even imagine how furious the Norwegians would be.
I'm kinda curious if they are gonna keep adding 5years or if they'll eventually dare to try and rehabilitate him.

you dont just set him free, he'll be in prison for 21 years

thats a long time

thats time enough for the most sadistic criminals to rehabilitate THEMSELVES, they do this by educating themselves, and their experiences in there are all part of the education

swear down some of you thought American History X was 'just a good story'

its an unpopular view, but that guy could have killed one person and you lot wouldn't give a shit, 77... NOW he's scum?! the amount of people you kill doesn't change the crime. thats why he got 21 years.

im gona keep repeating it though, if you can succeed in making this guy realise in just the smallest way that what he did was inhumane and at bottom wrong, you're winning the battle more than if you killed him when he still thought he was right.

[capo ultra]

you pay his shit then

[Forum]

American history x was a good film, well acted and everything but im pretty sure the major criticism of it has always been how unrealistic the main character's transformation is.

[Zambezi]

you pay his shit then

you regularly contribute to Norwegian prison funding?

[capo ultra]

I fail to see how American History X was anything more than just a good story, it wasn't a documentary based on painstaking real life evidence you know

[capo ultra]

you pay his shit then

you regularly contribute to Norwegian prison funding?

no but I burned a few churches back in the day

[noam]

@southstar

im sure what you meant to say was that YOUR main criticism of the film is how unrealistic YOU think the transformation is

the actual point is that there are reasons behind why certain people take those sorts of decisions, that people have motivating factors behind everything

some people are beyond rehabilitation but it doesn't mean all are.

and for that reason you dont just kill everyone who breaks the morality-mould.

you nmake it so they cant harm anyone else and try and reach them, at the very least you learn why...

[capo ultra]

I think we should kill him cos I watched Saw

[AxeD]

If people want to protect human rights, they should visit some women in Iran or kids in Thailand.

wot.

whoever brought up satisfying ones ego for the sake of rehabilitation... what in the fuck does ego have to do with bettering the planet??

killing a guy wont bring his victims back to life, rehabilitating him saves a life.

think about that

I don't see where I brought up anything about ego. I just think that it's crap to talk about an awful murderer's rights,
when there's innocent people in pain because of the lack of these rights every day.

I don't need revenge. But I don't see why he deserves
a second chance in society, when he's completely sane and very enthusiastic about murdering innocent kids.
I've been close to people who help criminals rehabilitate all my life and I don't think I'll be having a nice cup of
tea with Breivik in 20 years.
Just my opinion though, not the first time I don't agree with you noam

[capo ultra]

what do you expect, his name's noam. he prob thinks the cia funded every right wing dictator of the last 50 years