Lichee wrote:Mr Hyde wrote:thing is, the ones ive seen aren't any lighter because the frames and wheels tend to be pretty shit compared to modern racing bikes (and breaks and gears don't weigh much anyway).
they aren't faster- otherwise people would do the tour de france on them! (even town riding they aren't faster- not as quick accelerating or top speed without gears)
loads of people don't even have them fixed, which is the only advantage i can see if using clip ins and having better control for trackstanding at lights and stuff.
they were used by NY couriers because they needed to get them on their shoulders into buildings- dont want cables and gears getting all caught up, and wanted them as light as possible and used use decent frame and wheels....for a courier somewhere flat like manhatten they are quite practical. for 99% of the uses people have of them they aren't.
if you had two identical bikes and one had gears and one was a fixie, the fixie would be lighter.
they are faster - that's why the Olympic track cyclists use them, the same cyclists that go faster than those in the tour de france
then it's not a fixie??
you're just saying that good fixies in the right environment are better, which is my exact point?
well, for starters i don't know why you took what i said as some personal attack on something you said...and yeah, that is what im saying!
im not completely against fixies, where did i say i was?!? just saying that the majority of them are'nt even any lighter than racing bikes because they are fashion items (saw one with a copper frame the other day) and the savings in gear/break weight dosn't add up to much, for general town riding they are gonna be slower than the equivilant bike with gears and breaks (perhaps 1kg heavier at most but the ability to go loads faster up/down hills and accelerating) and modern gears don't really need much more maintainance than one that is fixed.
yep, velodrome type cycling im sure is better fixed, as is manhatten riding/carying your bike in buildings if you are a courier.
99% of the bikes and uses that people have for them are not as practical as alternatives though.
but shit, people ride unicycles, not saying people shouldn't be on fixies if thats what they wanna do, just that they aren't generally faster or more practical than bikes with gears