Page 2 of 5
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Sun Apr 14, 2013 5:31 pm
by Audio Animals
YeahItsMe wrote:Simulant wrote:Mr_Frost wrote:truth! i've been converting all my youtube rips to 24bit wavs and the difference in sound quality is huge.
What, so if you record an mp3 from youtube then convert to 24bit wave, it improves the quality? Wow, I didn't know that.
Really?? Wouldn't the quality worsen since you are trying to enhace what you don't have a full image of? Like zooming in on a crappy picture is what I would think.
Not to sound like this guy, but are ripping your favorite artists tracks or just remixes you can't buy? If you're serious about you music and what people to buy yours, you should do the same. Just saying... the industry is bad enough as it is with big labels, cut and paste pop artists who get a lot of $$ behind them, and 2 million radio stations rhat play the same 50 songs every year at the same time.
Support Music & Support Your Favorite Artists My Friends
Well said
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Mon Apr 15, 2013 7:25 am
by syrup
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Mon Apr 15, 2013 10:18 am
by Brothulhu
Lmao some real important ones on that list, the pronunciation of deadmau5 especially
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Mon Apr 15, 2013 3:18 pm
by FAARE FACED
The biggest downside of wav to me is metadata..
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Mon Apr 15, 2013 4:11 pm
by OfficialDAPT
why write an article when no one thinks that mp3 is better than wav
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Mon Apr 15, 2013 7:58 pm
by Audio Animals
OfficialDAPT wrote:why write an article when no one thinks that mp3 is better than wav
You'd be surprised how many "producers" don't know what a wav is. About time someone explained it to them
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Mon Apr 15, 2013 8:03 pm
by Brothulhu
It's easy to explain why a wav is better than an mp3 technically, no one is denying that but it doesn't mean an mp3 is more useful or more appropriate in certain situations
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Mon Apr 15, 2013 8:28 pm
by Simulant
Audio Animals wrote:OfficialDAPT wrote:why write an article when no one thinks that mp3 is better than wav
You'd be surprised how many "producers" don't know what a wav is. About time someone explained it to them
Seeing as how the default export is a wave file, i find that hard to believe.
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Tue Apr 16, 2013 12:08 am
by skimpi
lol this thread is so waste, obviously wav is better than mp3, it is always going to be better quality than mp3. Still though, no matter how much data you throw at me, it still doesnt change the fact that 320 mp3s dont sound that noticeably bad to me, and most people cant even tell the different when listening. When I say most people, i mean the general public, dont start chatting shit at me how you can tell the difference. You probably wouldnt be able to tell 50% of the time anyway.
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Tue Apr 16, 2013 12:11 am
by Brothulhu
skimpi wrote:lol this thread is so waste, obviously wav is better than mp3, it is always going to be better quality than mp3. Still though, no matter how much data you throw at me, it still doesnt change the fact that 320 mp3s dont sound that noticeably bad to me, and most people cant even tell the different when listening. When I say most people, i mean the general public, dont start chatting shit at me how you can tell the difference. You probably wouldnt be able to tell 50% of the time anyway.
Amen
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Tue Apr 16, 2013 1:49 am
by Mr_Frost
skimpi wrote:lol this thread is so waste, obviously orange juice is better than sunny delight, it is always going to be better quality than sunny delight. Still though, no matter how much juice you throw at me, it still doesnt change the fact that sunny d's dont taste that noticeably bad to me, and most people cant even tell the different when drinking. When I say most people, i mean the general public, dont start chatting shit at me how you can tell the difference. You probably wouldnt be able to tell 50% of the time anyway.
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Tue Apr 16, 2013 2:18 am
by Audio Animals
Simulant wrote:Audio Animals wrote:OfficialDAPT wrote:why write an article when no one thinks that mp3 is better than wav
You'd be surprised how many "producers" don't know what a wav is. About time someone explained it to them
Seeing as how the default export is a wave file, i find that hard to believe.
yeah and they switch it from wav to mp3.
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Tue Apr 16, 2013 6:35 am
by jrisreal
Many of these are paraphrased versions of eachother.
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Tue Apr 16, 2013 7:29 am
by Marcus
We all know it's better but most people have awful audio set ups and just stick their music on low storage devices such as their MP3 players.
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Tue Apr 16, 2013 9:42 am
by outbound
skimpi wrote:lol this thread is so waste, obviously wav is better than mp3, it is always going to be better quality than mp3. Still though, no matter how much data you throw at me, it still doesnt change the fact that 320 mp3s dont sound that noticeably bad to me, and most people cant even tell the different when listening. When I say most people, i mean the general public, dont start chatting shit at me how you can tell the difference. You probably wouldnt be able to tell 50% of the time anyway.
I mostly agree with this.
Although through my setup it is quite obvious a lot of the time the difference between the 2 (and for that matter the differences between different MP3 encoding rates*) I would certainly say that MP3 still is as very much relevant now as ever. Yes the quality is slightly lower however the fact it's filesize is much smaller making it quicker to upload and download (Yes internet speeds are getting better but the fact is when dealing with a lot of files at once e.g trying to send someone a collection of your dubs these little bits add up) metadata as someone else mentioned, as well as storage. (For DJ's that probably have a vast music library, you can store around x5 times more on any chosen medium than if you were to use WAV.)
I don't think MP3 will be about forever, we already have FLAC which is lossless and takes up much less room than WAV (also supports metadata) the only shame is that although there are a fair few players that support this, it isn't as popular as other formats and not every player will play them. I think we will eventually have if not this format something similar that has the portability of an MP3 but in a lossless state, bringing the best of both worlds.
*(Quite easy to tell if someone is chatting B/S too, simply get a song at WAV duplicate and compress one to MP3 and do a blind test)
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Tue Apr 16, 2013 10:45 am
by Brothulhu
Mr_Frost wrote:skimpi wrote:lol this thread is so waste, obviously orange juice is better than sunny delight, it is always going to be better quality than sunny delight. Still though, no matter how much juice you throw at me, it still doesnt change the fact that sunny d's dont taste that noticeably bad to me, and most people cant even tell the different when drinking. When I say most people, i mean the general public, dont start chatting shit at me how you can tell the difference. You probably wouldnt be able to tell 50% of the time anyway.
I can tell the difference no bother cos I fucking love Sunny D (the old stuff not the new healthy kind, that would be more of a challenge)
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Tue Apr 16, 2013 1:11 pm
by Mason
people who care about the difference already know and people who don't care will never care, pointless article imo.
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Tue Apr 16, 2013 2:00 pm
by Today
its not about internet speed or storage its about duplication speed when i' trying to dump a thousand of them from one drive to another. I'll keep my 320's. Not like i don't have lossless backups of all my music anyway.
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Tue Apr 16, 2013 3:29 pm
by Mark-Creda
YeahItsMe wrote:Simulant wrote:Mr_Frost wrote:truth! i've been converting all my youtube rips to 24bit wavs and the difference in sound quality is huge.
What, so if you record an mp3 from youtube then convert to 24bit wave, it improves the quality? Wow, I didn't know that.
Really?? Wouldn't the quality worsen since you are trying to enhace what you don't have a full image of? Like zooming in on a crappy picture is what I would think.
Not to sound like this guy, but are ripping your favorite artists tracks or just remixes you can't buy? If you're serious about you music and what people to buy yours, you should do the same. Just saying... the industry is bad enough as it is with big labels, cut and paste pop artists who get a lot of $$ behind them, and 2 million radio stations rhat play the same 50 songs every year at the same time.
Support Music & Support Your Favorite Artists My Friends
Could NOT of said this better myself.
I really hate people ripping off music etc
Also while there are fair points by all I really can not see how a MP3 is better then .WAV
Re: 20 Reasons Why WAV Is Better Than MP3 ( By Silent Code )
Posted: Tue Apr 16, 2013 3:54 pm
by Marcus
