pluses:
+i.love. the original song... got so excited when i saw the name pop up
+fat beat, hard not to make their words sound good haha
+kept the original vibe of the song
+money to blow-uh-oh-oh... sorry i had to say it
+snare is meaty meaty
advice:
-the half time, snare on the third beat is about the only dubstep i hear in this song
-sounds like the original tune with a new beat under it, which isnt bad but could use some surprises and variation
-wheres the bass? was waiting for a drop that never happened
-vocals are a little low-fi.. did you extract them yourself? maybe find a higher quality acapella if you didnt, sounds a little 32kbps
overall:
=good idea, good effort! had me groovin but sounds like a different version of a rap song, not dubstep.. would love to hear some classic dubstep bass sounds mixed in, some drops, some breaks, some vocal tweaking, maybe a surprise sample about money here and there...
much love
Re: PUT YOUR FINISHED TRACKS HERE FOR FEEDBACK.
Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2010 5:37 pm
by knell
Sharmaji wrote:damn knell-- kudos for giving folks proper input.
that's how i roll! thanks for the kudos.. found you on myspace and listened to your tracks, so i'm glad those words came from a superPro.
im going for a "polite simon cowell" feel for my reviews ... ill always be helpful and kind but theres no point in writing reviews if im not brutally honest
much love
Re: PUT YOUR FINISHED TRACKS HERE FOR FEEDBACK.
Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2010 5:58 pm
by knell
whew.. got all the generals out of the way, still working on replying to all the PMs...
my fingers are cramping.. so now it's your turn! give my myspace (link in sig) a visit/listen, and give me a biggup or youSuck where i can see it, and i'd much appreciate it! ill give ya all the review you can handle as thanks
much love
Re: PUT YOUR FINISHED TRACKS HERE FOR FEEDBACK.
Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2010 6:30 pm
by dedman
yeah I will do later, I think I'm going to get on the review thing as well, works nicely man!
Re: PUT YOUR FINISHED TRACKS HERE FOR FEEDBACK.
Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2010 6:32 pm
by BananaBomber
Track In My Soundcloud Cheers
Re: PUT YOUR FINISHED TRACKS HERE FOR FEEDBACK.
Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2010 6:41 pm
by marshy
BananaBomber wrote:Track In My Soundcloud Cheers
This track should be ft. Rolf Harris, pretty sure i can hear a wobble board at 46 seconds!
Seriously though, this is a step above the other tracks you've got. A nice mixture of synths and basses so it doesn't get boring, a common problem in simple wobble tracks. I like the general stop-startness of the track but there are points when you just need it to flow a little more. If this was played out you don't want the crowd to be stood waiting!
The automated bass at 1:50 is better, i noticed you used something like it sparingly in your last track too. Mess around with it more, include it as a more prominent part! A funky automation is what you need to really make a unique wobble.
Overall a definite improvement, keep it up! Just mess around more with automation inside your tracks (not just for the bassline LFO, search the forum for other automation tips) , and give it that flow that's oh so common (Saying that though, is it a good thing to follow the 'oh so common?)
This track should be ft. Rolf Harris, pretty sure i can hear a wobble board at 46 seconds!
Seriously though, this is a step above the other tracks you've got. A nice mixture of synths and basses so it doesn't get boring, a common problem in simple wobble tracks. I like the general stop-startness of the track but there are points when you just need it to flow a little more. If this was played out you don't want the crowd to be stood waiting!
The automated bass at 1:50 is better, i noticed you used something like it sparingly in your last track too. Mess around with it more, include it as a more prominent part! A funky automation is what you need to really make a unique wobble.
Overall a definite improvement, keep it up! Just mess around more with automation inside your tracks (not just for the bassline LFO, search the forum for other automation tips) , and give it that flow that's oh so common (Saying that though, is it a good thing to follow the 'oh so common?)
super win, marshy!!! i agree/second his review, took the words outta my mouth
+beat comes in nicely
+start/stop makes it almost horror movie-esque
+super subtraction synths
+lol at Marshy's Rolf Harris comment
-bit at 1:30 would sound super nasty if you alternated the saw line with some of your later automation
=overall, filth filth! super job, can definitely see your growth as a producer, keep it up
Easy mate,
Cool idea for a remix, left me feeling a bit like maybe you could have used a better quality vocal sample or maybe letting some more of the high end of the vocals through, feels like they could cut through alot more!
The drums sounds are nice, could maybe do with a bit more punch when the main synths are playing..
The main synth sounds nice, a kind of aggresive but soft feel that im digging, and i always enjoy alot of glide going on!
Automation and variations nice too, but feel it could be a tad long at 7 mintues?
Having said that the little breaks sound wicked,could maybe with do a bit less of the vocals going throughout the entire track!
All in all, this is a big track, and with a few some alterations and maybe some work on the sub, could see this being a real big track!
Re: PUT YOUR FINISHED TRACKS HERE FOR FEEDBACK.
Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2010 7:35 pm
by martello
Finished:
Re: PUT YOUR FINISHED TRACKS HERE FOR FEEDBACK.
Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2010 7:43 pm
by dedman
martello wrote:Finished:
Don't even know what to say accept amazing track!
Structure is amazing, i'm loving the sounds, the warm sub and the entire way the song builds up. This is the kind of dubstep you want when its 5am and your out of your skull.. going to listen to your others now, amazing!
EDIT:
Just hit the drop oh my days that bass line is amazing. Can't rate this tune enough.. any 320s haha?
pluses:
+nice heavy bass with super sweet twitchy oscillations, very nice
+ambience hits the spot, gives bells a new place in dubstep
+had me bobbing my head like i'd broken my neck
+nice builds and breaks
+crisp, well done, production wise
+white noise snare done like a pro
advice:
-first of all man, the harder you concentrate on getting signed, the less likely it will happen. put your focus into your music and getting your name to the right places, do it for the right reasons and have fun, and the rest will happen naturally if it's meant to be.
-gotta switch it up for the second drop, either timbre or automation (you have the right idea at 3:33).. no one likes copy and paste unless it's a timeless line
-cut the main riffs down time-wise if you dont want to switch it up to lessen the repetition
overall:
=you've got the right stuff man, but you've got to come up with something super original and put on a banging show if you're looking to get signed to a name-worthy label.. super clean production certainly helps, keep working on your tracks even when you think they're done, just listen to them over and over and imagine what you would want to hear in the song if you were a clubber to keep yourself interested. that way, you will have something that you and everyone else will love
much love and biggup
mate thanks for your time and feed back!!!!!!
will take on all the advice's
thanks you very much.
Re: PUT YOUR FINISHED TRACKS HERE FOR FEEDBACK.
Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2010 10:12 pm
by Chinch
Thanks for the feed bacl Knell!
Your making this section of the forum GO!!
Mad Proppers!!!
Re: PUT YOUR FINISHED TRACKS HERE FOR FEEDBACK.
Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2010 10:20 pm
by knell
Chinch wrote:Thanks for the feed bacl Knell!
Your making this section of the forum GO!!
Mad Proppers!!!
thank ya thank ya!
more reviews to come... but listening to all this music has inspired me to make some of my own!! plus the weather here is splendid.. i have to go outside before it gets dark, cant turn into a mole
plus:
+clip clop feel adds a nice bop to the track, giving it, dare i say.. swagga
+bass drops are nice and fat, really come out with the big subs
+smooth flow, would love to bump something like this on a long road trip with a nice system
+ending took me by surprise for sure
advice:
-hmm, are you sure this is a remix of the Datsik/Excision track and not the Jay-Z track "All I Need"? definitely sounds far more like the latter to me
-plasma blast lead needs to be altered/switched up somewhere in the track.. gets irritating fairly quickly, especially through quality tweeters..
-vocal work is clever and varied, but can also get to be a little much by the end of the track.. maybe put in some of the verse from 'all i need' in there?
-stronger bassline needed, theres almost no notes, just drops... a fat under melody would destroy some heads
-drags quite a bit, needs a surprise or two in there
overall:
=hmm. well it's a great idea to remix a classic song like 'all i need', but giving it a title with datsik and excision in it makes people expect a lot more, if anything they're waiting for something more brutal than their work, which is pretty timeless..
hit the studio and work on a fat, unique bassline and mix some of jay's smooth rhymes in there and you'll have some club butter that will make everybody glide
thanks for the advice
I kinda like calling it a remix of Swagga cause its still using the same vocal sample Excision and Datsik did but I just used another sample from All I Need if you get what I'm saying.
I'll work on making the bassline a bit more melodic.
pluses:
+oscillating ambience?? did you do that just for me or something?? haha well done
+vocal sample is gold, super sweet and surprising, fits oh so nicely
+dreamz dreamz dreamz when the twitchy little bass comes in
+drop is nice and sticky, would get me bobbing for sure
+oo the bass starts to growl when it drops on that run down, then the dong sweeps it back up... massive!
advice:
-beat is a little staggered and glitchy, gives it a weird flow.. interesting, but not my taste... but im not hugely impressed with Burial, so i must be insane, right?
-variation seems to come a little late in the track, i was waiting for something like the bass rundown (3:42) to happen a little earlier, then something a little more complex towards the end
overall:
=has a nice Burial vibe to it, but a little more sweet and listenable, to me anyway. this is dream hop at its finest, in my opinion, and would probably tear me up (like tearing up in my eyes, not like tearing shredding), if i were zonked in a good crowd grooving to this song. biggup, its just about finished!
much love
thanks for the feedback above - you're putting some great detailed feedback up for peoples here
will post with changes.
Re: PUT YOUR FINISHED TRACKS HERE FOR FEEDBACK.
Posted: Wed Jan 06, 2010 10:50 pm
by JFK
Yo. New track on the myspace in my sig "1000 yd stare". Kinda more chilled and sinister than normal..... Fuck it Im pleased with it
Any feedback will be appreciated and reciprocated gents